3U JRWRZDQLH PHEOL U V, 0RQWD XU G HQLD U VXQNL, HPRQWD XU G HQLD, gQHPOL Do NODPDODU



3U]\JRWRZDQLHPHEOLU\V 

0HEOHZ]DEXGRZLHRGSRUQHQDWHPSHUDWXUęPLQLPXPƒ&
2WZyUXVXQĉþZLyU\SRZ\NRQDQLXZ\FLęFLD
3RZLHU]FKQLHZ\FLęFLDXV]F]HOQLþPDWHULDãHPRGSRUQ\PQD

Z\VRNĉWHPSHUDWXUę
0RQWDŰQDV]DIFHU\VXQHN D
%ODWSRZLQLHQPLHþJUXERŔþPLQLPXP PP
:HQW\ODFMD2GVWęSPLęG]\SRZLHU]FKQLĉEODWXURERF]HJRLJyUQĉ

F]ęŔFLĉV]XIODG\PXVLZ\QRVLþ PP
:VND]yZND -HŰHOL Z V]XIODG]LH ]QDMGXMĉ VLę SU]HGPLRW\ NWyUH QD

VNXWHNF\UNXODFMLSRZLHWU]DSRGF]DVZHQW\ODFMLSã\W\JU]HZF]HM

PRJĉXOHFSRGJU]DQLXOXEMHŔOLZV]XIODG]LHSU]HFKRZ\ZDQHVĉ

QLHZLHONLH RVWUH PHWDORZH SU]HGPLRW\ MDN QS URŰHQ QDOHŰ\ XŰ\þ

Sã\W\SU]HJUDG]DMĉFHM] GUHZQD  U\V 
3ã\WD JU]HZF]D Z\SRVDŰRQD MHVW RG VSRGX Z ZHQW\ODWRU %H] Sã\W\

SU]HJUDG]DMĉFHM QLH ZROQR Z V]XIODG]LH SU]HFKRZ\ZDþ QLHZLHONLFK

F]\RVWU\FKSU]HGPLRWyZSDSLHUXOXEUęF]QLNyZNXFKHQQ\FK

0RJãRE\WRPLHþQHJDW\ZQHRGG]LDã\ZDQLHQDZHQW\ODWRU

SU]HGPLRW\PRJã\E\]RVWDþZHVVDQH 3RPLęG]\]DZDUWRŔFLĉ

V]XIODG\ D ZHQW\ODWRUHP QDOHŰ\ ]DFKRZDþ PLQLPDOQ\ RGVWęS  FP
0RQWDŰQDSLHNDUQLNXU\VXQHNE
%ODWSRZLQLHQPLHþJUXERŔþPLQLPXP  PP
:VND]yZND 6SUDZG]Lþ PRŰOLZRŔFL PRQWDŰX Z LQVWUXNFML PRQWDŰX

SLHNDUQLND MHŔOL WU]HED ]ZLęNV]\þ RGVWęS PLęG]\ Sã\Wĉ JU]HZF]ĉ D

SLHNDUQLNLHP
:HQW\ODFMD2GVWęSPLęG]\SLHNDUQLNLHPDSã\WĉJU]HZF]ĉ

SRZLQLHQZ\QRVLþFRQDMPQLHMPP
:VND]yZND -HŔOLSã\WDJU]HZF]D]RVWDQLHZEXGRZDQDQDG

SLHNDUQLNLHP LQQHM PDUNL QDOHŰ\ ]DVWRVRZDþ Sã\Wę SU]HJUDG]DMĉFĉ

]GUHZQD  U\V 
:HQW\ODFMDU\VXQHN 
:FHOX]DSHZQLHQLDSUDZLGãRZHJRG]LDãDQLDXU]ĉG]HQLDQDOHŰ\

]DGEDþRSUDZLGãRZĉZHQW\ODFMęSã\W\JU]HZF]HM
3RQLHZDŰZHQW\ODFMDZGROQHMF]ęŔFLXU]ĉG]HQLDZ\PDJD

]DSHZQLHQLDZ\VWDUF]DMĉFHJRGRSã\ZXŔZLHŰHJRSRZLHWU]D

QDOHŰ\]DGEDþRRGSRZLHGQLHSU]\JRWRZDQLHPHEOL1DOHŰ\SU]\

W\PXZ]JOęGQLþ

PLQLPDOQ\RGVWęSPLęG]\W\OQĉŔFLDQNĉPHEODDŔFLDQĉNXFKQL

RUD]PLęG]\SRZLHU]FKQLĉEODWXURERF]HJRDJyUQĉF]ęŔFLĉ

V]XIODG\  U\V D 

RWZyUQDJyU]HW\OQHMŔFLDQNLPHEOD  U\V E 

-HŰHOLPLQLPDOQ\RGVWęS PP]W\ãXPHEODQLH]RVWDã

XZ]JOęGQLRQ\QDOHŰ\Z\NRQDþRWZyUQDVSRG]LH  U\V F 

:VND]yZNL

:SU]\SDGNXPRQWDŰXXU]ĉG]HQLDZUDPDFKZ\VS\NXFKHQQHM

OXEZLQQ\PQLHZ\PLHQLRQ\PPLHMVFXQDOHŰ\]DSHZQLþ

RGSRZLHGQLĉZHQW\ODFMęSã\W\JU]HZF]HM

'ROQ\FRNyãQDOHŰ\KHUPHW\F]QLHXV]F]HOQLþ

0RQWDŰXU]ĉG]HQLDU\VXQNL 

:VND]yZND 3RGF]DVPRQWDŰXSã\W\JU]HZF]HMXŰ\ZDþUęNDZLF

RFKURQQ\FK3RZLHU]FKQLHNWyUHQLHVĉZLGRF]QHPRJĉPLHþ

RVWUHNUDZęG]LH
:SU]\SDGNXXU]ĉG]HĿEH]ZVWęSQLH]DLQVWDORZDQHJR

SU]HZRGXXPLHŔFLþSU]HZyG]DVLODMĉF\ZJQLHŮG]LH

SU]\ãĉF]HQLRZ\P



3ã\WęJU]HZF]ĉREUyFLþLSRãRŰ\þQDGQLHRSDNRZDQLDQD

ŔFLHUHF]FHOXEQDLQQHMSRZLHU]FKQLDE\XQLNQĉþ]DU\VRZDĿ



=DSRPRFĉZNUęWDNDSRGQLHŔþSRNU\ZęJQLD]GD

SU]\ãĉF]HQLRZHJR  U\V  



2GNUęFLþŔUXEęPRFXMĉFĉL]DSRPRFĉZNUęWDNDXQLHŔþRSDVNę

]DFLVNRZĉ  U\V 



3RGãĉF]DþGRJQLD]GDSU]\ãĉF]HQLRZHJRZ\ãĉF]QLH]JRGQLH]

U\VXQNLHP  U\V  
%1EUĉ]RZ\
%8QLHELHVNL
*1<(ŰyãW\L]LHORQ\
:VND]yZNL

:UD]LHSRWU]HE\]PLHQLþXNãDGPRVWNyZ]JRGQLH]H

VFKHPDWHPSRãĉF]HĿ

=ZUyFLþXZDJęDE\ŔUXE\ZJQLHŮG]LHSU]\ãĉF]HQLRZ\P

]RVWDã\GRNUęFRQHSRSRGãĉF]HQLXSU]HZRGyZ



3U]HZyG ]DVLODMĉF\ SU]\PRFRZDþ ]D SRPRFĉ RSDVNL ]DFLVNRZHM

LGRNUęFLþŔUXEęPRFXMĉFĉ  U\V D 



=DPNQĉþSRNU\ZęJQLD]GDSU]\ãĉF]HQLRZHJR
:VND]yZND 8PLHŔFLþSU]HZyGZŔURGNRZHMF]ęŔFLJQLD]GD

SU]\ãĉF]HQLRZHJRDE\XãDWZLþ]DPNQLęFLH



-HŰHOLSU]HZyG]DVLODMĉF\QDFKRG]LQDV]XIODGęSU]\PRFRZDþ

SU]HZyG]DSRPRFĉGRãĉF]RQHJRãĉF]QLNDNDEOLGRVSRGXSã\W\

JU]HZF]HM  U\V E 

:VND]yZND -HŔOLZ\PDJDQ\MHVWGãXŰV]\SU]HZyG]DVLODMĉF\

QDOHŰ\VNRQWDNWRZDþVLę]VHUZLVHP'RVWęSQHVĉSU]HZRG\

SU]\ãĉF]HQLRZHRGãXJRŔFLGR P
0RQWDŰSã\W\JU]HZF]HMU\V 
'RSDVRZDþSã\WęJU]HZF]ĉ]SU]RGXZQęNLGR]DEXGRZ\L

QDVDG]Lþ

3U]HZRGX]DVLODMĉFHJRQLHSU]\FLQDþDQLQLHSURZDG]LþSR

RVWU\FKNUDZęG]LDFK-HŔOLSRGSã\WĉJU]HZF]ĉZEXGRZDQ\MHVW

SLHNDUQLNZyZF]DVSU]HZyG]QDMGXMĉF\VLę]W\ãXSLHNDUQLND

QDOHŰ\SRSURZDG]LþGRJQLD]GDSU]\ãĉF]HQLRZHJR3U]HZyG

QDOHŰ\]DLQVWDORZDþZWDNLVSRVyEDE\QLHGRW\NDãJRUĉF\FK

HOHPHQWyZSã\W\JU]HZF]HMDQLSLHNDUQLND

: SU]\SDGNX EODWyZ URERF]\FK Z\ãRŰRQ\FK Sã\WNDPL XV]F]HOQLþ

IXJLNDXF]XNLHPVLOLNRQRZ\P

3RGãĉF]DQLHXU]ĉG]HQLDU\V

1DSLęFLHSDWU]WDEOLF]ND]QDPLRQRZD

3RGãĉF]DþZ\ãĉF]QLH]JRGQLH]HVFKHPDWHPSRãĉF]HĿ
%1EUĉ]RZ\
%8QLHELHVNL
*1<(ŰyãW\L]LHORQ\

:VND]yZND 6SUDZG]DQLH JRWRZRŔFL GR SUDF\ MHŔOL QD ZVNDŮQLNX

XU]ĉG]HQLDSRMDZLVLę

—…‹‹



“‹†‚„

OXE

XU]ĉG]HQLHQLHMHVW

SUDZLGãRZR SRGãĉF]RQH 2GãĉF]\þ XU]ĉG]HQLH RG VLHFL L VSUDZG]Lþ

SRGãĉF]HQLHSU]HZRGXHOHNWU\F]QHJR

'HPRQWDŰXU]ĉG]HQLD

2GãĉF]\þXU]ĉG]HQLHRGVLHFLHOHNWU\F]QHM
: 1LHEH]SLHF]HĿVWZRSRUDŰHQLDSUĉGHP
3U]\ RGãĉF]DQLX Sã\W\ JU]HZF]HM RG VLHFL HOHNWU\F]QHM Z ]DFLVNDFK

PRŰH]QDMGRZDþVLęMHV]F]HQDSLęFLHUHV]WNRZH3U]\ãĉF]H

HOHNWU\F]QHPRŰHE\þZ\NRQDQHZ\ãĉF]QLHSU]H]XSUDZQLRQHJR

VSHFMDOLVWę
1DFLVQĉþSã\WęJU]HZF]ĉRGVSRGXLZ\MĉþMĉ
8ZDJD
8V]NRG]HQLHXU]ĉG]HQLD1LHSUyERZDþZ\MPRZDþXU]ĉG]HQLDRG

JyU\

tr

ô

0RQWDMN×ODYX]X

gQHPOLDo×NODPDODU

*YHQOLNNXOODQ×PHVQDV×QGDJYHQOLNVDGHFHWHVLVLüOHPLQLQ

WHNQLNDo×GDQGRùUXYHPRQWDMWDOLPDWODU×QDX\JXQELUüHNLOGH

\DS×OP×üROPDV×GXUXPXQGDJDUDQWLHGLOPHNWHGLU8\JXQüHNLOGH

\DS×OPD\DQPRQWDMGDQND\QDNODQDQKDVDUODUPRQWDM×\DSDQ×Q

VRUXPOXOXùXQGDG×U
0RQWDMVRQUDV×QGDNXOODQ×F×Q×QHOHNWULNSDUoDODU×QDHULüLP

VDùOD\DPD\DFDù×QGDQHPLQROXQX]
%XFLKD]×QD]DPLUDN×PO×\HUOHUGHNXOODQ×OPDV×QDL]LQYHULOLU
: (OHNWURQLNLPSODQWWDü×\DQODU
&LKD]GDNDO×F×P×NQDW×VODUPHYFXWRODELOLU%XP×NQDW×VODU

HOHNWURQLNLPSODQWDV\RQODU×|UQHùLQNDOSSLOLQLYH\DLQVOLQ

SRPSDODU×Q×HWNLOH\HELOLU%XQHGHQOHPRQWDMV×UDV×QGDHOHNWURQLN

LPSODQWWDü×\DQODUHQD]FPX]DNGXUPDO×G×U
(OHNWULNEDùODQW×V×VDGHFH\HWNLOLELUX]PDQWHNQLV\HQLQ

VRUXPOXOXùXQGD'DKDVRQUDE|OJHQL]GHNLHOHNWULNWHGDULN

üLUNHWLQLQL]QLLOH\|QHWLOLU
&LKD]VDELWELUNXUXOXPDEDùO×ROPDO×YHüHEHNHG]HQOHPHOHUL

X\DU×QFDELUNHVPHüDOWHUL\OHGRQDW×OP×üROPDO×G×U
%DùODQW×WLSLD\J×WNRUXPDV×Q×I× , \DDLWWLUYHVDGHFHWRSUDNODPD

EDùODQW×V×LOHNRPELQDV\RQKDOLQGHNXOODQ×ODELOLU
hUHWLFL\DQO×üNXOODQ×PGDQYHX\JXQROPD\DQHOHNWULN

NXUXOXPODU×QGDQND\QDNODQDQKDVDUODUGDQVRUXPOXROPD\DFDNW×U
ûHEHNH NDEORVX 2FDù×Q EDùODQW× NXWXVXQGD EDùO× KDOGH YH\D

FLKD]OD WHVOLP HGLOPLü RODELOLUYH VDGHFH HùLWLPOL X]PDQ WHUFLKHQ

PüWHULKL]PHWOHULSHUVRQHOLWDUDI×QGDQNXUXOPDO×G×U*HUHNOL

EDùODQW×YHULOHULWLSSODNDV×QGDYHEDùODQW×UHVPLQGHEHOLUWLOPLüWLU
6DGHFHFLKD]ODWHVOLPHGLOHQYH\DWHNQLNPüWHULKL]PHWOHULQGHQ

WHGDULNHGLOHQNDEORNXOODQ×OPDO×G×U
dDO×üPDWH]JDK×DOW×QDPRQWDMĮQGNVL\RQOXRFDNVDGHFH

oHNPHFHOHULQ]HULQHYH\DIDQKDYDODQG×UPDO×I×U×QODUDPRQWH

HGLOHELOLU2FDNDOW×QDEX]GRODE×EXODü×NPDNLQHVL

KDYDODQG×UPDV×]I×U×QODUYH\DoDPDü×UPDNLQHOHULPRQWHHGLOHPH]
'DYOXPED]EDFDV×'DYOXPED]EDFDV×LOHRFDNDUDV×QGDNL

PHVDIHHQD]PRQWDMN×ODYX]XQGDGDYOXPED]EDFDV×LoLQ

EHOLUOHQHQPHVDIHNDGDUROPDO×G×U