9RRUEHUHLGLQJ YDQ GH PHXEHOV DIEHHOGLQJ, SSDUDDW LQERXZHQ DIE



: 'UDJHUVYDQHOHNWURQLVFKHLPSODQWDWHQ
+HW DSSDUDDW NDQ SHUPDQHQWPDJQHWHQ EHYDWWHQ GLH HOHNWURQLVFKH

LPSODQWDWHQ]RDOVSDFHPDNHUVRILQVXOLQHSRPSHQNXQQHQ

EHwQYORHGHQ+RXGGDDURPELMGHPRQWDJHHHQDIVWDQGYDQ

PLQVWHQVFPWRWHOHNWURQLVFKHLPSODQWDWHQDDQ
(OHNWULVFKHDDQVOXLWLQJGH]HPDJDOOHHQZRUGHQXLWJHYRHUG

GRRUHHQEHYRHJGYDNPDQ'H]HZRUGWJHUHJHOGGRRUGH

YRRUVFKULIWHQYDQGHHOHNWULFLWHLWVPDDWVFKDSSLMYDQGH]RQH
+HWDSSDUDDWGLHQWRSHHQYDVWHLQVWDOODWLHWH]LMQDDQJHVORWHQHQ

GHEHWUHIIHQGHVFKHLGLQJVVFKDNHODDUVPRHWHQFRQIRUPGH

LQVWDOODWLHYRRUVFKULIWHQZRUGHQJHPRQWHHUG
7\SH DDQVOXLWLQJ KHW DSSDUDDW EHKRRUW WRW EHVFKHUPLQJVNODVVH ,

HQPDJDOOHHQZRUGHQJHEUXLNWLQFRPELQDWLHPHWHHQDDQVOXLWLQJ

PHWDDUGJHOHLGLQJ
'HIDEULNDQWLVQLHWDDQVSUDNHOLMNYRRUGHRQJHVFKLNWHZHUNLQJHQ

GHPRJHOLMNHVFKDGHYHURRU]DDNWGRRURQJHVFKLNWHHOHNWULVFKH

LQVWDOODWLHV
1HWNDEHOGH]HLVPRJHOLMNDORSGHDDQVOXLWER[YDQGH

NRRNSODDWDDQJHVORWHQRILQEHJUHSHQELMGHOHYHULQJYDQKHW

DSSDUDDWHQPDJDOOHHQGRRUJHNZDOLILFHHUGSHUVRQHHORIHHQ

PHGHZHUNHUYDQGHVHUYLFHGLHQVWZRUGHQJHwQVWDOOHHUG'H

YHUHLVWHDDQVOXLWJHJHYHQVVWDDQRSKHWW\SHSODDWMHHQLQKHW

DDQVOXLWVFKHPD
$OOHHQGHELMKHWDSSDUDDWPHHJHOHYHUGHRIGRRUGHWHFKQLVFKH

VHUYLFHGLHQVWJHOHYHUGHNDEHOJHEUXLNHQ
0RQWDJHRQGHUKHWZHUNEODG'HLQGXFWLHNRRNSODDWNDQDOOHHQ

ZRUGHQJHwQVWDOOHHUGERYHQODGHQRIRYHQVPHWOXFKWYHQWLODWLH

2QGHUGHNRRNSODDWNXQQHQJHHQNRHONDVWHQYDDWZDVPDFKLQHV

RYHQV]RQGHUYHQWLODWLHRIZDVPDFKLQHVZRUGHQLQJHERXZG
$I]XLJNDS 'H DIVWDQG WXVVHQ GH DI]XLJNDS HQ GH NRRNSODDW GLHQW

WHQ PLQVWH WH YROGRHQ DDQ GH DIVWDQG GLH ZRUGW ZHHUJHJHYHQ LQ GH

PRQWDJHKDQGOHLGLQJYRRUGHDI]XLJNDS
:HUNEODGYODNKRUL]RQWDDOVWDELHO9ROJGHLQVWUXFWLHVYDQGH

IDEULNDQWYDQKHWZHUNEODGRS
:DQQHHUGHGLNWHYDQKHWZHUNEODGZDDULQGHNRRNSODDWZRUGW

JHPRQWHHUG QLHW DDQ GH YHUHLVWH PDDW YROGRHW PRHW KHW ZHUNEODG

PHWKLWWHHQZDWHUEHVWHQGLJPDWHULDDOZRUGHQYHUVWHYLJGWRWGH

DDQEHYROHQ PLQLPDOH GLNWH LV EHUHLNW $QGHUV NDQ JHHQ YROGRHQGH

VWDELOLWHLWZRUGHQJHJDUDQGHHUG

+HWZHUNEODGZDDULQGHNRRNSODDWZRUGWJHPRQWHHUGPRHW

EHVWDQG]LMQWHJHQHHQEHODVWLQJYDQFD NJ

&RQWUROHHUSDVRIGHNRRNSODDWYODNVWDDWDOVKLMLVJHPRQWHHUG

*DUDQWLHHHQRQJHVFKLNWHLQVWDOODWLHDDQVOXLWLQJRIPRQWDJH

KRXGWKHWYHUOLHVYDQGHJHOGLJKHLGYDQGHJDUDQWLHYDQKHW

SURGXFWLQ
$DQZLM]LQJ (ONH PDQLSXODWLH LQ KHW DSSDUDDW PHW LQEHJULS YDQ GH

YHUYDQJLQJYDQGHYRHGLQJVNDEHOPRHWZRUGHQXLWJHYRHUGGRRU

SHUVRQHHO YDQ GH 7HFKQLVFKH 'LHQVW PHW HHQ VSHFLILHNH RSOHLGLQJ

9RRUEHUHLGLQJYDQGHPHXEHOVDIEHHOGLQJ 

,QERXZPHXEHOHQWHQPLQVWHEHVWDQGWHJHQHHQWHPSHUDWXXU

YDQƒ&
9ULMHUXLPWHYHUZLMGHUGHVSDDQGHUVQDGHVQLMZHUN]DDPKHGHQ
6QLMRSSHUYODNNHQDIGLFKWHQPHWKLWWHEHVWHQGLJPDWHULDDO
0RQWDJHRSGHODGHDIEHHOGLQJ D
:HUNEODGPRHWHHQGLNWHKHEEHQYDQWHQPLQVWH PP
9HQWLODWLH'HDIVWDQGWXVVHQKHWRSSHUYODNYDQKHWZHUNEODGHQ

GHERYHQNDQWYDQGHODGHPRHW PPEHGUDJHQ
$DQZLM]LQJ :DQQHHUPHWDOHQYRRUZHUSHQLQGHODGHWLMGHQVGH

YHQWLODWLHYDQGHNRRNSODDWZDUPZRUGHQRIDOVHULQGHODGH

NOHLQHSXQWLJHPHWDOHQYRRUZHUSHQZRUGHQEHZDDUG]RDOV

YOHHVVSLH]HQGLHQWHHQWXVVHQVFKRWYDQKRXWWHZRUGHQJHEUXLNW

$IE  
'HNRRNSODDWEHVFKLNWDDQGHRQGHUNDQWRYHUHHQYHQWLODWRU

=RQGHUWXVVHQVFKRWPRJHQHULQGHODGHJHHQNOHLQHRISXQWLJH

YRRUZHUSHQSDSLHURIYDDWGRHNHQZRUGHQEHZDDUG'LWNDQ

LQYORHGKHEEHQRSGHNRHOLQJRIGHYHQWLODWRUNDQGRRUDDQ]XLJHQ

EHVFKDGLJG UDNHQ 7XVVHQ GH LQKRXG YDQ GH ODGH HQ GH YHQWLODWRU

LQJDQJPRHWHHQPLQLPDOHDIVWDQGYDQ FPZRUGHQ

DDQJHKRXGHQ
0RQWDJHRSHHQRYHQDIEHHOGLQJE
:HUNEODGPRHWHHQGLNWHKHEEHQYDQWHQPLQVWH  PP
$DQZLM]LQJ :DQQHHU GH DIVWDQG WXVVHQ NRRNSODDW HQ RYHQ JURWHU

PRHW]LMQUDDGSOHHJGDQKHWLQVWDOODWLHYRRUVFKULIWELMGHRYHQ
9HQWLODWLHGHDIVWDQGWXVVHQGHRYHQHQGHNRRNSODDWGLHQW

PLQVWHQVPPWHEHGUDJHQ
$DQZLM]LQJ :RUGWGHNRRNSODDWLQJHERXZGERYHQHHQRYHQYDQ

HHQDQGHUPHUNGDQGLHQWHHQWXVVHQVFKRWYDQKRXWWHZRUGHQ

JHEUXLNW  $IE 

9HQWLODWLHDIEHHOGLQJ 
2PHHQMXLVWHZHUNLQJYDQKHWDSSDUDDWWHJDUDQGHUHQPRHWGH

NRRNSODDWQDDUEHKRUHQZRUGHQJHYHQWLOHHUG
2PGDWYRRUGHYHQWLODWLHRQGHULQKHWDSSDUDDWHHQYROGRHQGH

DDQYRHUYDQYHUVHOXFKWYHUHLVWLVPRHWHQGHPHXEHOVKLHURS

EHUHNHQG]LMQ+LHUYRRULVKHWYROJHQGHYHUHLVW

HHQPLQLPDOHDIVWDQGWXVVHQGHDFKWHUNDQWYDQKHWPHXEHOHQ

GH NHXNHQZDQG HQ WXVVHQ KHW RSSHUYODN YDQ KHW ZHUNEODG HQ GH

ERYHQNDQWYDQGHODGH  $IE D 

HHQ RSHQLQJ ERYHQ DDQ GH DFKWHUNDQW YDQ KHW PHXEHO  $IE E 

LQGLHQ DDQ GH DFKWHUNDQW YDQ KHW PHXEHO JHHQ PLQLPDOH DIVWDQG

YDQPPDDQZH]LJLVPRHWGHRQGHUNDQWYDQHHQRSHQLQJ

ZRUGHQYRRU]LHQ  $IE F 

$DQZLM]LQJHQ

:DQQHHUKHWDSSDUDDWLQHHQNHXNHQHLODQGRIRSHHQDQGHUH

QLHWEHVFKUHYHQSODDWVZRUGWLQJHERXZGGLHQWGHNRRNSODDW

YRRU]LHQWH]LMQYDQHHQSDVVHQGHYHQWLODWLH

'HRQGHUVWHSOLQWQLHWKHUPHWLVFKDIVOXLWHQ

$SSDUDDWLQERXZHQDIE 

$DQZLM]LQJ %LMKHWLQERXZHQYDQGHNRRNSODDWGLHQWX

YHLOLJKHLGVKDQGVFKRHQHQWHGUDJHQ'HQLHW]LFKWEDUH

RSSHUYODNNHQNXQQHQVFKHUSHNDQWHQKHEEHQ
%LM DSSDUDWHQ ]RQGHU YRRUDI JHwQVWDOOHHUGH NDEHO GH QHWNDEHO

LQGHDDQVOXLWGRRVVWHNHQ



'HNRRNSODDWRPGUDDLHQHQRSGHYHUSDNNLQJHHQGRHNRIHHQ

DQGHURSSHUYODNOHJJHQRPNUDVVHQWHYRRUNRPHQ



+HWGHNVHOYDQGHDDQVOXLWGRRVPEYHHQVFKURHYHQGUDDLHU

RSWLOOHQ  $IE  



'HEHYHVWLJLQJVVFKURHIORVGUDDLHQHQGHVODQJNOHPPEYHHQ

VFKURHYHQGUDDLHURSWLOOHQ  $IE 



$OOHHQDDQVOXLWHQYROJHQVGHDIEHHOGLQJRSGHFRQWDFWGRRV

$IE  
%1%UXLQ
%8%ODXZ
*1<(*HHOHQJURHQ
$DQZLM]LQJHQ

'HSODDWVLQJYDQGHEUXJJHQ]RQRGLJYHUDQGHUHQDDQGH

KDQGYDQKHWDDQVOXLWVFKHPD

/HWHURSGDWGHVFKURHYHQYDQGHFRQWDFWGRRVQDGDWGH

NDEHOV]LMQDDQJHVORWHQZRUGHQYDVWJHGUDDLG



'HYRHGLQJVNDEHOPHWGHVODQJNOHPEHYHVWLJHQHQGH

EHYHVWLJLQJVVFKURHIDDQWUHNNHQ  $IE D 



'HGHNVHOYDQGHFRQWDFWGRRVVOXLWHQ
$DQZLM]LQJ 'H NDEHOV LQ KHW PLGGHOVWH GHHO YDQ GH FRQWDFWGRRV

SODDWVHQRPKHWVOXLWHQWHYHUJHPDNNHOLMNHQ



:DQQHHUGHQHWNDEHOLQWHUIHUHHUWPHWGHELMJHYRHJGH

NDEHOELQGHUGHNDEHOPHWGHELMJHYRHJGHNDEHOELQGHU

EHYHVWLJHQDDQGHRQGHUNDQWYDQGHNRRNSODDW  $IE E 

$DQZLM]LQJ ,VHUHHQODQJHUHQHWNDEHOQRGLJQHHPGDQFRQWDFW

RSPHWGHVHUYLFHGLHQVW(U]LMQNDEHOVWRW PEHVFKLNEDDU
.RRNSODDWLQEUHQJHQDIE 
'HNRRNSODDWLQKHWYRRUVWHGHHOYDQGHLQERXZQLVDIVWHOOHQHQ

LQEUHQJHQ

=RUJHUYRRUGDWGHYRHGLQJVNDEHOQLHWEHNOHPGUDDNWHQQLHW

RYHUVFKHUSHUDQGHQZRUGWJHOHLG,VHUHHQRYHQRQGHUGH

NRRNSODDWJHSODDWVWGDQGHNDEHOYLDGHDFKWHUVWHKRHNHQYDQ

GH RYHQ QDDU GH DDQVOXLWGRRV OHLGHQ 'H OHLGLQJ PRHW ]R ZRUGHQ

JHwQVWDOOHHUGGDWHUJHHQFRQWDFWZRUGWJHPDDNWPHWKHWH

SODDWVHQYDQGHNRRNSODDWRIGHRYHQ

%LMEHWHJHOGHZHUNEODGHQGHYRHJHQYDQGHWHJHOVDIGLFKWHQ

PHWVLOLFRQHQUXEEHU

$SSDUDDWDDQVOXLWHQDIE

6SDQQLQJ]LHKHWW\SHSODDWMH

8LWVOXLWHQGDDQVOXLWHQYROJHQVKHWDDQVOXLWVFKHPD
%1%UXLQ
%8%ODXZ
*1<(*HHOHQJURHQ

$DQZLM]LQJ &RQWUROHHURIKHWDSSDUDDWNODDULVYRRUJHEUXLN

YHUVFKLMQW

—…‹‹



“‹†‚„

RI

RSKHWGLVSOD\YDQKHWDSSDUDDW

GDQ LV KHW QLHW JRHG DDQJHVORWHQ+DDO GH VWHNNHU YDQ KHW DSSDUDDW

GDQXLWKHWVWRSFRQWDFWHQFRQWUROHHUGHDDQVOXLWLQJYDQGH

HOHNWULFLWHLWVNDEHO