0RELO DQ Q KD UODQPDV HNLO, LKD Q PRQWDM HNLOOHU, LKD Q GHPRQWDM



*DUDQWL\DQO×üNXUXOXPEDùODQW×\DGDPRQWDMUQQ

JDUDQWLVLQLQJHoHUOLOLùLQL\LWLUPHVLQH\RODoDFDNW×U
%LOJL %HVOHPHNDEORVXQXQGHùLüLPLGHGDKLOROPDN]HUHFLKD]×Q

LoHULVLQGH\DS×ODFDNKHUWUOLüOHP|]HOHùLWLPOL'HVWHN6HUYLV

WHNQLNSHUVRQHOLWDUDI×QGDQ\DS×OPDO×G×U

0RELO\DQ×QKD]×UODQPDV×ûHNLO

*|PPHPRELO\DODUHQD]ƒ&×V×\DGD\DQ×NO×G×UODU
*LULQWLNHVPHLüOHULQGHQVRQUDWDODüODU×WHPL]OH\LQL]
.HVPH\]H\OHUL×V×\DGD\DQ×NO×ELUPDO]HPHLOHPKUOH\LQL]
dHNPHFHQLQ]HULQGHPRQWDMüHNLO D
7H]JDKHQD] PPNDO×QO×ùDVDKLSROPDO×G×U
+DYDODQG×UPDdDO×üPDWH]JDK×\]H\LLOHoHNPHFHVWDODQ×

DUDV×QGDNLPHVDIHPPROPDO×G×U
%LOJL 2FDù×QKDYDODQG×U×OPDV×V×UDV×QGDKDYDGHYULGDLPL

QHGHQL\OHoHNPHFHGHNLPHWDOLNQHVQHOHU×V×Q×\RUVDYH\D

oHNPHFHGHHWüLüLJLELNoNVLYULPHWDOLNFLVLPOHUVDNODPDN

LVWL\RUVDQ×]  ûHNLO  DKüDSWDQLPDOHGLOHQELUDUD]HPLQ

NXOODQ×Q×]
2FDù×QDOWN×VP×QGDELUIDQPHYFXWWXU$UD]HPLQROPDGDQ

oHNPHFHGHNoNYH\DVLYULFLVLPOHUNDù×WYH\DNDù×WKDYOXODU

PXKDID]DHGLOPHPHOLGLU6RùXWPDVLVWHPLHWNLOHQHELOLUYH\DIDQ

HPPHV×UDV×QGDKDVDUJ|UHELOLUdHNPHFHQLQLoN×VP×LOHIDQJLULüL

DUDV×QGDHQD] FPPHVDIHROPDO×G×U
)×U×Q]HULQHPRQWDMüHNLOE
7H]JDKVDKLSROPDV×JHUHNHQPLQLPXPNDO×QO×N  PP GLU
%LOJL (ùHURFDNYHI×U×QDUDV×QGDNLPHVDIHQLQDUW×U×OPDV×

JHUHNLUVHI×U×Q×QPRQWDMN×ODYX]XQDEDN×Q×]
+DYDODQG×UPD)×U×QLOHRFDNDUDV×QGDNLPHVDIHHQD]PP

ROPDO×G×U
%LOJL 2FDNEDüNDPDUNDELUI×U×Q]HULQHPRQWHHGLOPLüVH

DKüDSWDQELUDUD]HPLQNXOODQ×Q×]  ûHNLO 
+DYDODQG×UPDüHNLO 
&LKD]×QGRùUXELoLPGHoDO×üPDV×Q×JDUDQWLOHPHNLoLQRFDN

\HWHULQFHKDYDODQG×U×OPDO×G×U
+DYDODQG×UPDLoLQFLKD]×QDOW×QGDNLDODQGD\HWHULQFHWHPL]KDYD

JLULüLQHLKWL\DoGX\XOGXùXQGDQPRELO\DODUEXQDX\JXQRODUDN

\HUOHüWLULOPHOLGLU%XQXQLoLQDüDù×GDNLOHUJHUHNOLGLU

0RELO\DQ×QDUNDWDUDI×YHPXWIDNGXYDU×DUDV×QGDNLDVJDUL

PHVDIHYHoDO×üPDWH]JDK×\]H\LLOHoHNPHFHQLQVWWDUDI×

DUDV×QGDNLDVJDULPHVDIH  ûHNLOD 

0RELO\DQ×QDUNDWDUDI×QGDNLDo×NO×N  ûHNLOE 

0RELO\DQ×Q DUND WDUDI×QGD  PP DVJDUL PHVDIH \RNVD DOW WDUDID

ELUGHOLNDo×OPDO×G×U  ûHNLOF 

%LOJLOHU

(ùHUFLKD]ELUSLüLUPHDGDV×QDYH\DEDüNDWDQ×PODQPDP×üELU

\HUHPRQWHHGLOPLüVHRFDNLoLQX\JXQELUKDYDODQG×UPD

VDùODQPDO×G×U

$OWNDLGHKHUPHWLNRODUDNNDSDW×OPDPDO×G×U

&LKD]×QPRQWDM×ûHNLOOHU 

%LOJL 2FDù×QPRQWDM×LoLQNRUX\XFXHOGLYHQNXOODQ×Q×]

*|UQPH\HQ\]H\OHUGHNHVNLQNHQDUODURODELOLU
gQPRQWDMO×NDEORVXROPD\DQFLKD]ODUGDHOHNWULNNDEORVXQX

SUL]HWDN×Q×]



2FDù×WHUVoHYLULQL]YHoL]LOPHVLQLHQJHOOHPHNLoLQDPEDODM×Q

DOW×QDELUEH]YH\DEDüNDELU\]H\\HUOHüWLULQL]



3UL]NDSDù×Q×ELUWRUQDYLGD\DUG×P×\ODNDOG×U×Q×]  ûHNLO 



6DELWOHPHYLGDV×Q×V|NQ]YHKRUWXPNHOHSoHVLQLELUWRUQDYLGD

\DUG×P×\ODNDOG×U×Q×]  üHNLO 



6DGHFHüHNOHX\JXQELoLPGHSUL]HWDN×Q×]  ûHNLO  
%1.DKYHUHQJL
%80DYL
*1<(6DU×YH\HüLO
%.6L\DK
*<*UL
%LOJLOHU

(ùHUEDùODQW×/1EDùODQW×GL\DJUDP×QDJ|UH\DS×OP×üVD

N|SUOHULQG]HQLGL\DJUDPDJ|UHGHùLüWLULOPHOLGLU

3UL]YLGDODU×Q×QDQFDNNDEOREDùODQG×NWDQVRQUDV×N×OPDV×

JHUHNWLùLQHGLNNDWHGLQL]



(OHNWULNNDEORVXQXKRUWXPNHOHSoHVLLOHVDELWOH\LQL]VDELWOHPH

YLGDV×Q×V×N×Q×]  ûHNLO D 



3UL]LQNDSDù×Q×NDSDW×Q×]
%LOJL 3UL]LQRUWDV×QGDNLDODQGDEXOXQDQNDEOR\XNDSDWPD\×

NROD\ODüW×UDFDNELoLPGH\HUOHüWLULQL]



(ùHUHOHNWULNNDEORVXoHNPHFHLOHoDN×ü×\RUVDNDEOR\XNDEOR\OD

ELUOLNWHYHULOHQNDEOREDùOD\×F×V×LOHRFDù×QDOW×QDVDELWOH\LQL]

ûHNLO E 

%LOJL 'DKDX]XQELUüHEHNHEDùODQW×KDWW×QDLKWL\DoGX\XOPDV×

KDOLQGH OWIHQ PüWHUL KL]PHWOHUL LOH LUWLEDW NXUXQX] %DùODQW× KDWODU×

 PX]XQOXùDNDGDUPHYFXWWXU
2FDù×Q\HUOHüWLULOPHVLûHNLO
2FDNPRQWDMQLüLQLQ|QN×VP×QDD\DUODQPDO×YH\HUOHüWLULOPHOLGLU

(OHNWULNNDEORVXQXV×N×üW×UPD\×Q×]YHNHVNLQNHQDUODU]HULQGHQ

JHoLUPH\LQL]$QNDVWUHI×U×QODUGDKDWNDEORI×U×Q×QDUND

N|üHVLQGHQSUL]HoHNLOPHOLGLU+DWRFDù×QYH\DI×U×Q×QV×FDN

\HUOHULQHWHPDVHWPH\HFHNELoLPGHG|üHQPHOLGLU

)D\DQVNDSO×WH]JDKODUGD)D\DQVDUDO×NODU×Q×VLOLNRQNDXoXNLOH

GROGXUXQX]

&LKD]×QEDùODQPDV×ûHNLO

*HULOLP%N]7LSSODNDV×

6DGHFHEDùODQW×GL\DJUDP×QDX\JXQRODUDNEDùOD\×Q×]
%1.DKYHUHQJL
%80DYL
*1<(6DU×YH\HüLO
%.6L\DK
*<*UL

%DùODQW×WUQHEDùO×RODUDNIDEULNDWDUDI×QGDQWHVOLPHGLOHQ

EDùODQW×XoODU×Q×QG]HQLQLGHùLüWLUPHNJHUHNHELOLU%XQXQLoLQ

NOHPHQVOHULQN×VDOW×OPDV×YHLNLNDEOR\XELUOHüWLUHQNOHPHQVLQ

\HUOHüWLULOHELOPHVLLoLQL]RODV\RQXQo×NDUW×OPDV×JHUHNOLRODELOLU

%LOJL dDO×üPD\DKD]×UROPDGXUXPXQXQNRQWURO&LKD]×Q

J|VWHUJHVLQGH

—…‹‹



“‹†‚„ 

YH\D

J|UQ\RUVDFLKD]

EDùODQW×ODU×GRùUX\DS×OPDP×üW×U&LKD]×QHOHNWULNEDùODQW×V×Q×

NHVLQL]YHDN×PNDEORVXEDùODQW×ODU×Q×NRQWUROHGLQL]

&LKD]×QGHPRQWDM×

&LKD]×HOHNWULNüHEHNHVLQGHQD\×U×Q×]
: (OHNWULNoDUSPDWHKOLNHVL
2FDNEDùODQW×V×NHVLOLUNHQEDùODQW×ODUWHUVJHULOLPHQHGHQRODELOLU

(OHNWULNEDùODQW×V×VDGHFHELUX]PDQWDUDI×QGDQ

JHUoHNOHüWLULOPHOLGLU
2FDùDDOWWDQEDVW×UDUDNRFDù×o×NDU×Q×]
'LNNDW
&LKD]GDNLKDVDUODU&LKD]×NROODU]HULQGHQ\XNDU×GDQG×üDU×

oHNPH\HoDO×üPD\×Q×]

el

Ù

̯͉̻̓͆͂̾̈́͐̈́͂̀͒͑͒̀͑͆͐

̵͉͎̓͏͕͓͖͋͌̿›͇͇͓͑͆́͐͋

̥͔͍͇͔̻͈͉̻͕͗̾͋̓͆̀͑͊̈́̀̀͒͒͆͏͍͔͈͚͎̻̽͑͆̈́̀͑̀͊̾̈́͒̀͋͌̈́͌͆ͅ

͉̻̈́͂̀͒͑͒̀͑͆ ̼͈͂͌̈́ ͋̈́ ͚͑͗͑͒ ͒͏͚›͎ ͑̈́ ͕͈͉͚͒̈́͌ ̈́›̾›͎̈́̓ ͉͈̀ ͔͑͛͋͗͌̀

͈͎͎͋̈́͒͐̓͆͂̾̈́͐͒›͎͇̼̦͈̼͒͆͑͆͐͆͋͐›͎͓›͏͎͉͇͉͚͊̽͆̀͌͊͂͗͋͆

͎͑͗͑͒̽͐͒›͎͇̼͒͆͑͆͐̈́͋›̾›͎͓͓͇͎͓͉̻͒͌͑͒͆͌̈́͛͌͆͒̈́͂̀͒̀͑͒͒͆

̬̻͉̻̈́͒͒͆͌̈́͂̀͒͑͒̀͑͆›͏̼›͈͍͔͈͚͈͎͕̈́͌̀̈́̀͑̀͊͑͒̈́̾͒͏̽͑͒͆͐̓̈́͌

̼͕͈͉̈́̀͋̾̀›͏͚͉͑́̀͑͆͑͒̀͆͊̈́͒͏͈͉̻͍̈́̀͏͒̽͋̀͒̀

̢͓͓͉͓͈͉͉͒̽͆͑͑̈́̽̈́̾͌̀̈́͂̈́͏͈̼͈͕͋͌͆͂̀͏͖̼͕̽͑͆͑̈́͛͆͋͏͈͉͈̀

̼͋͒͏̀

: ̸͇͓͉͍͇͕͑͒́͌͒͑͏͋͌͟͏͔͕͇͚͑͋́͘͏͇͎͕͇͖͔͉͓͗͞
̧ ͓͉͓͑͑̈́̽ ͋›͎͏̈́̾ ͌̀ ›̈́͏͈̼͕͈̈́ ͚͈͎͓͋͌͋͐ ͋̀͂͌̽͒̈́͐ ͎͈ ͎›͎͎͈̾ ͋›͎͏͎͛͌

͌̀̈́›͆͏̻͎͓̈́͑͌̀͏͈͉̻͉͌͆͒͒̀͆͊̈́͒͏͎͈͉̻͎͈͕͔͓͌͑͒̈́̾̀̈́͋͛͒̈́͑͆͐›͕

͎͚͉́͆͋̀͒̓͒̈́͐̀͏͈̻͈͎͓̤͈̓͐̽̀͌͒͊̾̈́͐͌͑͊̾͌͆͐·͓͚͉̻̀͒̀͒͒͆

͓͑͌̀͏͎͚͋͊͂͆͑͆͒͆͏͈̻͕͈̽͑͒̈́͋̀̈́͊͑͒͆̀›͚͑͒̀͑͆FP̀›͚͒̀

͉͆͊̈́͒͏͎͈͉̻͎͈͕͔͓͌͑͒̈́̾̀̈́͋͛͒̈́͑͆͐

̵͞͏͇͔͉͔͕͉͍͇͕͇͎͚͎͓͆͑͌͒͋͌͒̓͋͌͝͞› ͓͇͚̈́͛͌͆̈́͌͐

͉͉̈́͂̈́͏̨͈̼͎͓͈͈͉͎͕͈͉͎͋͌̈́̓͛͒̈́͌͛̀›͏̼›͈͈̼̈́͌̀̓›͈̈́͒̀̀›͚͎͓͒͐

͉͚͈̀͌͌̈́͐͒͆͐̈́͒̀͏̈́̾̀͐›̀͏͎͕͉̽͐͆͊̈́͒͏͈͉͎͛͑͒͆›̈́͏͈͎͕̽
̧͓͉͓͑͑̈́̽›͏̼›͈͈͓̼͈͇̈́͌̀̈́̾͌̀͑͌̓̈́̓̈́͋͌͆͑̈́͋̀͑͒̀̈́͏̽

͉̻͉͈͔͈̈́͂̀͒͑͒̀͑͆̀͑͛͋͗͌̀͋̈́͒͐›͏͎͈̓̀͂͏͔̼̀͐›͏̼›͈̈́͌̀

͉͇͎͎͈͕͈̻͍͈͈͉͎̈́͂̀͒̀͑͒̀͛͌̀͌͒̾͑͒̈́͐̓̀͒̈́͐̓̀›̽͐
̶͞›͓͔͑͞͏͇͔͉͓͔͕͉͍͇͕͇͎͓͉͓͉͈͆͑͌͒͋͌͒̓͆͑͑̈́̽̀͌̽̈́͑͒͆͌͝͞

͉̻͊͑͆›͏͎͑͒̀͑̾̀͐ ,͉͈̀͋›͎͏͕̈́̾͌̀͏͈͎͆͑͋›͎͈͇͚͎͆̈́̾͋͌͑̈́

͓͓͚͎͉͑͌̓̀͑͋͋̈́͋̾̀͑͛͌̓̈́͑͆͑͒͆͊̈́͒͏͈͉͚͏͚̈́͛͋̀͋̈́̀͂͗͂͂̈́̾͗͑͆͐
̯͉͉͓͔̼̀͒̀͑̈́̀͑͒̽͐̓̈́͌͏͈͓͇͈͈͎͓̈́̈́͛͌͆͂̀͒͆͋͆͑͗͑͒̽͊̈́͒͏͉͈͂̾̀̀

͈͒͐›͈͇̼͈̼̀͌͐͆͋͐ͅ›͎͓›͏͎͉͇͉͚͉͊̽͆̀͌͊͂͗͋͆͑͗͑͒̽͐͆͊̈́͒͏͈͉̽͐

͉̻̈́͂̀͒͑͒̀͑͆͐
̭͍͔̓͆͋͑͟͞͏̨͇͔͉͓͆͏͇͎͆͑̿͘͏͚͓͇́͏͉͔͖̓͋̀͆͏͇͇͎͆͆̿͏͔͕͑͑

͖͕͔͌͑́͞͏͇͔͉͓͕͉͓͔͉͓͇͔͕͆̈́̾͋͟͏̀›͇͕͎͈͎͇͕͉̓͒̓͆́͆̓͋̓́

͔͖͔͇͖͌̀ ͉͈̀ ̈́›͈͒͏̼›͈̈́͒̀ ͌̀ ͉͇̈́͂̀͒̀͑͒̀̈́̾ ͚͎͋͌ ̀›͚ ̼͌̀͌ ͈͎͕͎̀̓̈́͛

͉͆͊̈́͒͏͎͚͎͊͂̽̀›͚͎͈͈͉͓̼͎͒̈́̓̈́͋͌›͏͎͑͗›͈͉͚͓͒͆͐›͆͏̈́͑̾̀͐

͍͓̈́›͆͏̼͒͆͑͆͐›̳̈́͊̀͒͌̀̀͜›̀͏͎͈͕̀̾͒͆͒̀͑͒̈́̾̀͑͛͌̓̈́͑͆͐

́͏͉͎͈̾͑͌͒̀͑͒͆͌›͈͉͌̀̾̓̀͒͛›͎͓͉͈͔̼̀̀͌̀͏͎͈͎͕̼͈͎͌͒̀͑͒͑̓

͑͛͌̓̈́͑͆͐